Avengers: Endgame’sCreators Keep Undoing the Good Will They Had by Explaining the Movie

While Avengers : Endgame is very good at drawing you intothe sheer spectacle of itselfas you ’re keep an eye on , when you give it some aloofness , the movie ’s narrative weaknessesbecomereadily unmistakable . And that ’s before the Russo Brothers started tofurther perplex thing with their post - hoc musings . Apparently , though , the filmmakers have even more to say .

The way Endgame ended up down off Black Widow for give the remaining Avengers the key to defeating Thanos is one of the most controversial component of the film . It ’s part of Endgame ’s big problem with pay lip avail to theidea of distaff character developmentrather than in reality going for it , full stop . After work Widow into the Avengers ’ newest leader , the pic does aside with her entirely when she sacrifice herself to retrieve the Soul Stone so that Hawkeye does n’t have to — and the choice put up a number of doubt , considering how , presumably , Scarlet Johansson ’s set toreturn to the MCU in her own solo movie .

While the Russos did n’t get into any kind of specific about when the Black Widow movie is meant to take place within the cinematic universe of discourse , in an audience with Slatethey explained that , at one breaker point , there were plans to use the character to explore the larger forking of Thanos ’ initial grab that wiped out half of the planet . That sounds interesting until Anthony Russo spells out on the nose what the directing duo mean :

Scarlet Johansson as Black Widow.

Scarlet Johansson as Black Widow.Image: (Marvel Studios)

One thing that we talked about a lot — and I think was really unplumbed , but it was almost too declamatory of an idea for us to wrangle , but we did essay for a while — is just the mind that one - quartern of all children have no parents . Assuming you started with two parents . So that ’s a lot of global orphans . Just the staggering routine of that .

I consider at one point really early in exploitation , Black Widow was actually leading the organisation in D.C. that was in charge of orphans , basically . That was what she was heading up five years later on .

Avengers : Age of Ultron insert the deeply perturbing , reductive idea that Black Widow examine herself as a goliath because of the Red Room subprogram that return her sterile ( though some argue this ) . Even though Endgame spends a meaning amount of time revisiting earlier moments from the MCU from new angles , this would have been a terrible way to close out that particular narrative thread for her .

Graphic: Jim Cooke

What ’s been so weird about all of this is that neither Endgame ’s directors nor its co - author seem to have a cohesive vision of how the picture really terminate , which has the effect of make everything they say now about the film feel reflective of their inability to agree upon one determinate story .

In an interview withthe Hollywood Reporter , Endgame co - writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely stated that in addition to believing that one of the recent Infinity Snapsmight have unknowingly created the MCU ’s multiverse , they ’re confident that Steve Rogers ended up staying in the past to marry Peggy Carter and start out a household with her . Specifically , Markus and McFeely said ( in what feel like a contradiction towhat the Russos said ) Peggy ’s two children name in Captain America : Winter Soldier might “ have somewhat tops soldier DNA . ”

Markus and McFeely accept that different people will have unlike stand on this topic . But , in their mind , Steve was Peggy ’s hubby all along .

Argentina’s President Javier Milei (left) and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., holding a chainsaw in a photo posted to Kennedy’s X account on May 27. 2025.

“ It was always our design that he was the father of those two children . But again , there are time traveling loophole for that , ” said McFeely .

Added Markus : “ It does introduce the idea that there are two children who have slightly super soldier DNA . ”

As interesting as this can be , one has to take at what point we ’re mean to accept the text of the film as it is and to stop wondering what might have been , had the film maker ended up score dissimilar decisions . In this display case , it ’s not just because Endgame is a mostly - fine picture on its own , but also because the more the writers and film director mouth , the more they make some of their ideas go less than ideal . So — how about we all give this a rest , and start looking forward towhatever ’s happening next .

William Duplessie