A Modern study did n’t find much of a difference between sound low - juicy and low - carb diet .

People on the two diets lost about the same amount of excess weight .

Participants were encouraged not just to go for low - carb or low - fatty options but to look for healthy , nourishing replacements .

After the study , participants ' attitudes to intellectual nourishment had changed for the skillful .

Dieting is a very personal challenge . A specific eat regimen your friend swears by just may not work for you , and inquiry has shown that there is probably no one - size of it - fits - all solution for system of weights passing .

Now , when it comes to the late pop enquiry of whether cutting carbs or fatty tissue is good , new inquiry from the Stanford University School of Medicine has recover it may not matter .

The report , publish in the Journal of the American Medical Association , keep up 609 overweight adults ages 18 to 50 , half men and half women , who were put on a healthy low-down - blubber dieting or a healthy grim - carbohydrate dieting for 12 months . About 20 % of the participant drop out because of fate .

Results showed that mass who trim back out carbs or fat while maintaining a healthy diet shaved off about the same balance of extra weight .

To describe for individual conflict , the participants did two pre - study activities . They had their genome sequence so the researchers could look for specific factor pattern that could enhance or bottle up weight personnel casualty , and they also received tests for level of insulin , a hormone produced the pancreas .

Overall , genome and insulin levels did n’t affect a mortal ’s achiever on either diet .

" We ’ve all heard account of a supporter who went on one diet — it worked great — and then another friend tried the same diet , and it did n’t wreak at all , " Christopher Gardner , a professor of medicine who was the jumper cable generator of the written report , say in a statement . " It ’s because we ’re all very dissimilar , and we ’re just set off to understand the reasons for this diversity . Maybe we should n’t be asking what ’s the best diet , but what ’s the best diet for whom ? "

Notably , study participants were promote to pursue goodish low - fat and down - carb diets , rather than allowing for diet washing soda or food that are n’t peculiarly alimental just because they are humbled in fatty tissue or carbs .

" We made certain to tell everybody , regardless of which dieting they were on , to go to the farmer ’s marketplace , and do n’t bribe treat convenience - food poop , " Gardner said . " Also , we advised them to diet in a fashion that did n’t make them feel thirsty or impoverish — otherwise it ’s hard to conserve the dieting in the long run .

" We want them to pick out a low - fat or low - carb dieting programme that they could potentially follow forever , rather than a diet that they ’d drop when the field ended . "

By the end of the 12 calendar month , participants miss 13 pounds on mean . But some people lost more than 60 British pound , while a few gained about 15 or 20 . The takeout food , the researchers say , is that move for healthy , nutritive options is the way fore .

" On both sides , we discover from mass who had lost the most weight that we had helped them change their relationship to food for thought , and that now they were more thoughtful about how they deplete , " Gardner said .

Read next on Business Insider : A subject area liken low - rich and low - carb diets may have break the real better diet for your body and wit